When the border becomes a barrier

November 19, 2026

A view across the Detroit River from Windsor to General Motors headquarters at the Renaissance Center in downtown Detroit.

Canada-U.S. tariffs are testing an automotive system built on continental integration — and experts warn the damage could outlast the trade war itself.

North America’s automotive industry has spent decades operating less like three separate national industries and more like one continental production system.

Vehicles, parts, capital and expertise move across borders on the assumption that trade rules will be predictable and access to the North American market will remain relatively frictionless.

That assumption is now under unprecedented strain.

When Canada-U.S. trade negotiations collapsed in August, the existing U.S. tariff regime on Canadian automobiles remained in place. U.S. President Donald Trump subsequently threatened to increase tariffs on Canadian cars, trucks, automotive parts and steel to 50 per cent beginning Jan. 1, 2027.

The broader trade dispute has also escalated. Canada imposed new counter-tariffs on $27.6 billion worth of U.S. imports in September, matching earlier U.S. measures, while existing Canadian counter-tariffs on U.S. automobiles remain in place.

Trump has made clear that moving automotive production into the United States is central to his strategy.

“We want to make the cars here,” Trump told reporters at the White House in August. “They can make their own cars if they want, and they can continue to make their cars for Canada. But we don’t want them to make cars for the United States of America.”

For Canada’s automotive sector, that raises an increasingly uncomfortable question: What happens if tariffs stop being a negotiating tactic and become a permanent feature of the North American industry?

An integrated industry under strain

Stephen Beatty

Stephen Beatty, the retired former vice-president and corporate secretary of Toyota Canada and a former chair of Global Automakers of Canada, has spent much of his career working at the intersection of automotive policy and international trade.

In March 2025, as the tariff dispute was beginning to unfold, Beatty delivered a webinar on Canada-U.S. trade for the Canadian Finance and Leasing Association.

He told Canadian auto dealer that even then, the automotive industry was already facing significant changes extending from manufacturing through to retail. In some respects, he said, the tariff dispute has distracted attention from those larger structural shifts.

An updated assessment today would be considerably darker.

“I guess what I would say today, knowing the way things have unfolded, there was and still might be some small chance that sanity prevails and you could get a reconstituted automotive trade deal in North America,” said Beatty. “But the chances for that seem increasingly slim.

“If we don’t get that, there is going to be not just a collapse of Canadian auto manufacturing and the supply chain but likely the collapse of North American manufacturing.”

Beatty points to Mexico as evidence that the pressure is not confined to Canada. Mexico’s automotive sector had lost approximately 107,000 jobs over the previous two years by April 2026.

“There’s a massive restructuring going on behind the scenes, and the only thing that holds those jobs together is if you manage to get the market working efficiently on a North American scale,” said Beatty.

“If that doesn’t happen, it becomes very difficult, I think, for the North American manufacturers — in other words, the U.S. brands — to succeed going forward.”

The cost of lost trust

Didi Caldwell

Didi Caldwell, president and CEO of Global Location Strategies, advises companies on where to locate major manufacturing operations. She believes one consequence of the trade dispute may endure regardless of where tariff rates ultimately settle.

Trust has been damaged.

“There’s been a lot of trust destroyed over this,” said Caldwell. “Even if the tariffs were eliminated tomorrow, I don’t necessarily believe the trust will come back immediately.”

The danger, she said, is that manufacturers begin duplicating operations on both sides of the border because they can no longer assume they will have reliable access to an integrated continental market.

“Companies are going to build more capacity on each side because they no longer trust they have frictionless access across the border,” said Caldwell. “That redundancy will create resilience, but that resilience is going to cost money, and that is going to show up in the P&L of automakers, suppliers, dealers and consumers. That is the downside.”

The better outcome, she said, would be a return to predictable trade rules — even if some tariffs remained.

Companies are going to build more capacity on each side because they no longer trust they have frictionless access across the border,” said Caldwell. “That redundancy will create resilience, but that resilience is going to cost money, and that is going to show up in the P&L of automakers, suppliers, dealers and consumers. That is the downside.

“The upside is we come back to something that was very predictable,” said Caldwell. “And if you have tariffs, it’s a low tariff rate that can be modelled and understood and planned for.”

The immediate consequence of uncertainty is that investment decisions are being delayed.

“There’s so many other things that are impacting the automotive industry right now, including electrification, economic uncertainty globally and in North America,” said Caldwell. “It could be anywhere from a year, maybe five years, before some of those major investments are being made.

“Right now we don’t know exactly how it’s going to settle out because every tit-for-tat retaliation becomes justification for the next retaliation. We’re still in that mode right now. Everyone’s kind of waiting to see where the chips are going to fall.”

Lucas Malinowski

Global Automakers of Canada President and CEO Lucas Malinowski said the same uncertainty is affecting manufacturers and importers on both sides of the border.

“It’s a steady frustration at the persistent uncertainty, so everyone is holding off on medium- and long-term decision making as far as they can, but that becomes increasingly challenging,” said Malinowski.

Canada remains the largest international market for the U.S. automotive industry, making the disruption a two-way problem.

“It’s frustrating and stressful for automakers on both sides of the border,” said Malinowski.

For Caldwell, the deterioration in the relationship itself is remarkable.

“It is pretty seismic, something that no one anticipated, no one was really prepared for,” said Caldwell. “You could say the USMCA was Trump’s singular best achievement in his first term, so no one really expected him to come into office and tear it up.”

Canada still has leverage

Canada does not have the economic weight of the United States, but the experts interviewed for this story argue that does not mean it is powerless.

Beatty said that if the United States ultimately makes Canadian vehicle manufacturing uncompetitive, Ottawa may have little reason to continue providing preferential access to American vehicles.

“Honestly, I don’t think Canada is going to be of the mood to allow American vehicles in duty-free if the White House has blown up the Canadian industries,” said Beatty.

“The result of all of that is there could be a lot of change of position of different brands in the marketplace. There will be the growth of Chinese imports and there could be a kind of catastrophic failure in the U.S. brands if things continue the way they are.”

Beatty said he takes Trump seriously when the President says he wants automotive production moved into the United States.

“Looking at it from Donald Trump’s perspective, he’s absolutely right — he doesn’t need Canadian cars, there’s lots of alternatives,” said Beatty. “But the problem for Trump, and one he has never recognized, is that he needs the Canadian market. I don’t think Canadians will be of a mind to just hand over the keys.”

Pickup trucks illustrate that leverage, he said.

“If you think about U.S. manufacturers, they have one specific area of specialty and that’s pickup trucks, and there is only one significant export market for those trucks and that’s Canada,” said Beatty.

“If Canada really wanted to inflict some pain, all it has to do is raise tariffs on pickup trucks. There would be a very serious body blow delivered by Canada if Ottawa were to take that sort of approach.”

The danger is where that path leads.

“There’s some mutual-assured destruction that comes from people that get locked into spiralling trade wars,” said Beatty. “What worries me more than all of that is that as we continue tit-for-tat stuff, that might eventually lead to an all-out economic war.”

Sam Fiorani

Sam Fiorani, vice-president of Global Vehicle Forecasting at AutoForecast Solutions, also questions the assumption that U.S.-built vehicles can simply be redirected to other markets.

“If there were a market for American-style vehicles in Japan, Toyota would already be making them,” said Fiorani. “If the Ford F-Series could find buyers in Europe, plants in Germany and Spain would be assembling them.

“The rest of the world isn’t banning the sale of American vehicles. They’re just not competitive outside of North America.”

Fiorani said putting tariffs between North American trading partners ultimately undermines the competitiveness of the same U.S. manufacturers the policy is intended to help.

“Adopting automotive industry tariffs across North American partner countries is short-sighted and demonstrates a misunderstanding of this industry that will harm General Motors, Ford and Stellantis,” said Fiorani. “But worse than that, it will limit choices and make vehicles more expensive for American buyers.”

Caldwell agrees that Canada can target its response.

“It’s not symmetric leverage, but it is a situation where Canadians can apply tariffs and their advantage is where it’s going to hurt the most economically and often the most politically,” said Caldwell.

“If we see that starting to happen, where the political pressure, be it the increase in costs and the economic pain, starts to become more apparent, I think the U.S. government will be forced to make some concessions.”

Canadian Border Services Agency sign in Surrey, B.C.

Politics may change the equation

The political calendar could also become increasingly important.

With U.S. midterm elections approaching and Trump’s approval ratings hovering near recent lows, Huw Williams, CADA’s Public Affairs, said the association is emphasizing that tariffs are imposing costs on the U.S. automotive industry as well as Canada’s.

“We think at the end of the day getting those American numbers out to an American audience or an automotive audience is tremendously important because the damage is not being done just to Canada, it’s being done to the U.S. economy,” said Williams.

CADA has been making that case to members of Congress and state governors.

“We’ve heard privately from Republicans that their red line in terms of giving the President latitude on trade has to do with USMCA,” said Williams.

“We are now seeing actions by the President that are completely undercutting USMCA in terms of constitutional responsibility. Congress has the constitutional power to set tariffs.”

Congress does hold constitutional authority over tariffs, although it has delegated considerable trade authority to presidents through legislation. The extent of those delegated powers has become an important part of the legal fight surrounding Trump’s tariff policies.

The dispute is also unfolding alongside the six-year joint review of CUSMA. The agreement remains in force until 2036, although failure by Canada, the United States and Mexico to agree on an extension would lead to annual reviews in the years ahead.

Williams said Congress will ultimately have to weigh the impact of the trade dispute against what American businesses and consumers want from the North American relationship.

With U.S. midterm elections approaching and Trump’s approval ratings hovering near recent lows, Huw Williams, CADA’s Public Affairs, said the association is emphasizing that tariffs are imposing costs on the U.S. automotive industry as well as Canada’s.

“The U.S. business community wants USMCA, free and fair trade with Canada, and the American people ultimately want the focus on affordability,” said Williams.

“It’s not delivering jobs or affordability at the moment.”

A strategy beyond retaliation

Beatty said court challenges could still alter parts of the tariff landscape, but warned that the administration has other trade authorities available if Trump remains committed to his current approach.

“This could go on for a long time and there are other tariff authorities that he has not used so far,” said Beatty. “So if Trump is committed to this course of action, and I think he is, we will see more twists and turns ahead.”

Canada launched a new federal automotive strategy earlier this year, but Beatty argues that the country needs something broader: a long-term industrial and trade strategy capable of defining Canada’s place in a rapidly changing global automotive industry.

He has advocated an approach drawing on some of the principles of the original Canada-U.S. Auto Pact.

“In other words, we need a plan, not just a tit-for-tat reaction to provocations from the White House,” said Beatty.

“While we are consumed with these issues, China has largely set new rules for the global industry and technology is rapidly evolving in the areas of vehicle connectivity, electrification and autonomy.

“We need to define our road map to the future, not just fight over the past.”

Related Articles
Share via
Copy link